
Stems From MIDI vs Stems Split From Audio: What Is the Difference?
Two ways to get stems
A stem is a separate audio file for one part of a song: the drums, the bass, the lead. Producers use stems to mix, process and remix each part on its own. When an AI makes a song, there are two very different ways to end up with stems.
Way one: split a finished mix
Most AI music tools generate a single finished audio file. To give you stems, they run that file through a separation model that tries to pull the parts back apart. It is clever work, and it has a built-in limit: the parts were already mixed together, so the model is guessing where one ends and the next begins. A little of the drums can end up in the bass file, or a hint of the pad in the lead. You often hear it when you solo a stem. If you want every part as MIDI instead, see song maker alternatives that give you MIDI.
Way two: render each part on its own
MIDI Lab works the other way round. It writes the song as MIDI first, with every part on its own track. It plays each track through its own synth patch or drum kit, and it saves each one as its own audio file. The parts are never mixed together at any point, so there is nothing to separate afterwards. The bass file holds the bass and nothing else. For a full arrangement from intro to outro, see the MIDI song generator.
What that changes in practice
Clean solos. Solo any stem in your DAW and you hear one part. Nothing from the rest of the song hides underneath it.
Everything lines up. Every file starts on bar 1 and ends on the same bar line. Drop them onto your timeline at the song tempo and they stay in time, with no nudging.
They add back up to the song. The stems come before the master processing, which keeps them honest. In our own tests, adding the stems back together reproduces the unprocessed mix to within a rounding error. The full mix file has the master processing applied, so you can compare your own chain against it.
You can change your mind. Because the song started as MIDI, you can still edit a note, swap a sound or switch off a lane, then download again. A stem split from a finished file cannot be edited this way. You would have to regenerate the whole song. You can make those edits in the online DAW.
When splitting is still the right tool
If you already have a finished recording and want to pull it apart, a separation model is the tool for that job, and MIDI Lab does not replace it. The approach above is about songs that start in MIDI Lab. For those, there is no finished mix to take apart.
Formats and plans
Every account can download the full mix as an MP3. Stems start at Maker as MP3, Pro adds 24 bit WAV, and Studio adds 24 bit AIFF. Downloading the audio costs no credits. See pricing for the plans, or read how it works.
Try it
Generate a song, open the Download button on its card and pick Audio. If you want to understand the difference between the MIDI and the audio first, start with MIDI vs Audio.